Last Updated On:
Arc welding involves the use of a power supply to create an electric arc between an electrode and the material intended to be welded to melt the metals at the welding point.
Any ac vs dc welder will have to understand that the power supply can use either direct (DC) or alternating (AC) current.
The type of current used can sometimes cause problems in welding.
Any electrical current is either a direct current (DC) or an alternating current (AC).
AC DC are terms that refer to the polarity of the electrical current that the welding machine creates and runs through the electrode.
Direct Current (DC) is electricity flowing in a constant direction and/or possessing a voltage with constant polarity, either positive or negative. Typical DC units include batteries and often used in low voltage devices such as cell phones and remote controls.
In welding, electrode negative (DC) or straight current provides faster deposition rates because there is quicker melt-off of the electrode. Electrode positive (DC) results in deeper penetration.
Alternating current (AC) is electricity that switches direction back and forth so the voltage also periodically reverses because the current changes direction.
Typical AC are what you would expect to see from your electrical outlets in your home and often used in higher voltage devices such as household appliances.
AC changes its polarity 120 times per second with a 60-hertz current. Reversed polarity (AC) results in deeper penetration.
In AC)welding, since the current and the magnetic field of the arc reverse direction many times a second, there is no net deflection of the arc.
There are a some distinctive differences between ac vs dc welding, these are:
- AC Weld Machinery is smaller then a DC welding machines
- AC Weld Machinery is lighter then most DC welding machines
- AC Weld Machinery is relatively easy to use while the DC welding is more difficult to handle
- AC Weld Machinery has a lower drop in voltage meaning it can be used further away, while the voltage drop on a DC machine is higher, so should be used at a closer distance
- AC Weld Machinery is usually not very expensive, whereas the DC welding machine can be pricey.
AC welding can be used to weld two or more magnetic metals.
This cannot be done with DC welding. AC welding is ideal for the following types of welds:
The primary advantage of using AC welding, is that it allows the ac welders to weld on magnetized materials.
In AC, the current changes direction and is not affected by magnetism. The arc remains stable and is easier to control.
AC welding is also the preferred method for:
The two biggest drawbacks to using AC welding is the quality of the weld. It is not as smooth as DC welding because of the continuous change in directional flow and there is likely to be more spatter.
Welding with DC is best used for:
As a rule of thumb, DC is preferred for welding because:
The primary drawbacks to using of DC welding are:
In welding, there can be a lot of reasons for a weld failure. One of the most frustrating is magnetic arc blow.
This occurs when a magnetic field is present in the area where the weld is being prepared to join two metal components.
The quality of the weld can be affected by magnetic disturbance due to the interaction of the magnetic field of the welding current with the residual magnetic field present in the metal.
The disturbance causes the welding arc to deflect away from the weld path and behave erratically.
The welding operator must fight arc blow by trying to keep the electrical current stable and the work usually suffers in quality. Arc blow occurs only in DC welding. An effective fix for the problem is to switch from DC to AC.
Overall the strength of the weld can be determined by many factors, such as:
A strong weld can be achieved in both AC welding and DC welding (ac dc) so long as you weld with the current and polarity appropriate for the material being welded.
It’s a matter of choosing the right one for your job.
That's the end of the ac dc debate. Hopefully you have all the information you need in the in the ac vs dc welding debate.
In order to achieve proper penetration, uniform beading and good welding results the correct current and polarity must be used when welding with any given metallic electrode.
Using incorrect current and polarity results in poor penetration, irregular bead shapes, excessive splatter, overheating, lack of arc control and quick burning of the electrode.
Be sure to research your materials and conditions so you can choose AC vs DC for the task at hand!
Hi, my name is Gregory! I have been welding practically all of my life and love it. As I have gotten older I have started to weld less and less, so in order to continue my love for welding I created this website. I like to write about my experiences and help you all become welders. I hope that you enjoy the site!